There’s always something to howl about.

Category: Carnival of Real Estate (page 2 of 2)

Why aren’t the Dinosaurs extinct already?

In my last post, I made the case that many of today’s old school brokers are Dead Dinosaurs Walking.

In the last couple of days, two things have happened that have me questioning that theory and its keeping me up at night:

  1. I learned that a intelligent guy I know, a programmer who actually works for Rent O Meter (a RE tech start up), bought his first house last week. He used an agent who was referred to him. He did not use the Web in his search process at all. He told the agent what he wanted and what he could afford and had no problem when every listing the agent showed him just happened to belong to the agent’s brokerage.

    He bought one of those listings, the broker scored a 6% double whammy,  our programmer friend could not be happier, he loves his agent and actually referred him to me. To add insult to injury, the broker’s Web site is really just awful. This transaction is straight out of 1983:

  2. Another friend, who is not connected to the business, read the post and pointed out that the asteroid that hit the Yucatan, blocking the sun and causing firestorms on a planetary scale, probably killed most of the dinosaurs in less than a year. If the widespread use of the Web is the asteroid that hit Real Estate, then the impact happened around Y2K. Its 8 years later and lots of business-as-usual brokers are still standing.

    How is it that brokers who refuse to evolve can tough it out for 8 years while Tyrannosaurus Rex was well on his way to being a skeleton in the Peabody Museum within 12 months?

The first comment on that post said, “If I’ve heard ‘I’ve sold hundreds of houses this way and there is no reason for me to change now’ once, I’ve heard it 100 times.”

What if that is right? That somehow, despite all the evidence to the contrary (this Blog being Exhibit A), Real Estate is immune, or shielded somehow, from what the Internet has done and is doing to businesses as diverse as Travel Read more

We’re off to beat the Wizard…

I found BloodHoundBlog by following a link from a comment Greg made on an Inman story that I had also commented on. It was pretty typical Inman fare — “Blog your way to a Fortune in Real Estate” was the implied headline. When I arrived here I felt like Dorothy waking up in her bed back in Kansas.

I am new to the Real Estate “industry”. I put that in quotes, because “industry” implies the production of something other than nausea when sellers see the commission they paid (BA DUM DUM – Crash! But I kid the Realtors…). I began working with brokers after building a career as an eCommerce consultant. That was in the real world, which for the purposes of the metaphor I will beat to death in this post, we will call “Kansas”.

That makes Real Estate “Oz” for all the many reasons that have been documented here over the past two years.

Full disclosure: I have spent the last two years trying to bring eCommerce Best Practices from Kansas to Oz. The centerpiece of that effort is a IDX Search platform called “Foyer” that is powered by Google Search Technology. I guess that makes me a vendor, but I am not a carny barker. So far, every gig we have is from a referral. Its been a slow way to grow, but its kept us honest. Its also the best marketing we can afford.

With that out of the way,  you want to know why you should bother to read what I have to say, so to give you an idea of where I am coming from, I will finish the beating of the metaphor.

If I’m Dorothy, then, in no particular order:

Lollipop Guild: Real Estate Agents. Obviously.

The Wizard: The NAR/Move Inc/Realtor.com cartel. Behind the scenes of an imposing edifice The Wiz is an old man pulling big levers (one is labeled “MLS”) that are no longer attached to anything. The Wizard’s power is derived from the size of the Lollipop Guild. The stature of the Guild members indicates the height of the barriers to entry set by the Wiz. When Bloodhounds Read more

The Odysseus Medal competition will be postponed this week

We’re busy with real estate stuff, and I’m grinding on all gears to push engenu out the door. Plus which, there were only 65 nominations, suggesting, perhaps, that the rest of the world has Teri’s Spring fever.

In the mean time, here’s a blog post from Mark Steyn illustrating why a reactive, me-too, catch-up strategy is likely to fail in the net.world:

Old media dinosaurs looking to the Internet to make up for declining print sales will find this analysis disquieting:

In the first three months of this year, the average amount of time visitors spent on newspaper sites fell by 2.9% to 44 minutes and 18 seconds per month, or less than 1½ minutes per day. In the same period, the average number of pages viewed per unique site visitor dropped by 6.6% to 47.2 per month…

The decline in the average duration of sessions at newspaper web pages suggests that visitors are not utilizing the industry’s sites as primary destinations, but, rather, as places to episodically view individual articles highlighted by Google News, Drudge, Digg, blogs or any of the thousands of other places they might be.

So, if you happen to see a link at, say, NRO to something in the Minneapolis Star-Tribune, you’ll click and read it, and then go away and not return to the paper until you click another link that tickles your fancy. That’s a hard model to sell to advertisers.

American newspapers have only themselves to blame. Instead of recognizing the necessity to reinvent their approach online, for the most part they simply transferred their old dullness to the new technology. Their print drabness derived mostly from the complacency of their local monopoly, and that’s the one thing you can’t transfer to the Internet. It will take more than the web to save these sclerotic franchises.

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

In Search of Excellence

That, of course, was the name of a best-selling management book that came out in the early eighties. It not so much defined my market philosophy as confirmed what I’d already learned from Nordstrom: Concentrate on excellence and rewards will follow. Concentrate on rewards, and you’re pretty much assured of being consigned to mediocrity.

What’s been interesting to watch in the twenty five or so intervening years isn’t so much that nearly every business gives lip service to the tenet, but what’s happened to the definition of ‘excellence’. The education establishment meets failing test scores by dumbing down the tests. Grades are allocated not on merit, but on the perceived sensitivities of the students, just as soccer games are played without keeping score so as not to hurt anyone’s feelings. You can get an undergrad English Lit degree at the University of Washington without ever having studied Shakespeare. In the frenetic twenty-first “I want it now!” century reading has become a chore, replaced by vapid visual stimulation and fifteen minute podcasts. Writing skills have devolved to YouTube. Joseph Conrad need not apply.

So what? Here’s so what: Words matter. Reading builds vocabulary, writing exercises its use. But not only is someone who draws on 150,000 words able to communicate concepts better than one who’s limited to the normal 50,000, but he or she is infinitely better able to conceive them in the first place. I’ve said — often — that good writers invariably make good thinkers, largely because they do.

All of which was going through my mind as I read this weekend’s BHB posts.

Whew. Excellent.

Before I started my own RE blog I searched the internet to see how others were doing it. Lots of people giving advice, most of it in the genre of Kris’ exquisite satire: Keep it short, be witty, illustrate cleverly. Most blogs seemed to keep diligently to that formula, but two things were apparent: that A) Most were blogging just to be blogging, and not to be actually saying anything; and B) the “Keep it short” formula was necessary to mask an inability to string words Read more

Super Bowl? But there’s a Carnival of Real Estate going on . . . !

On second thought, maybe we are the nerdliest joint on the RE.net. I actually watched much of the Super Bowl yesterday, but it was only because it was coming between me and the judging for the Carnival of Real Estate. BloodhoundBlog is host to the 28th edition of the Carnival, and, geek that I am, that was far more interesting to me than watching the Colts stampede the Bears.

And, yes, we are geeks with pride. Snotty sardonic surly teenaged web-programmer god Cameron built us a little bot that would permit multiple judges to view and score each article “blind,” with no knowledge of either the author or weblog. And wise winsome willowy spreadsheet goddess Cathleen Collins built an Excel bot that combined all the results into a one-page report.

These were our judges, six out of the eleven of us: Kris Berg, Brian Brady, Cathleen Collins, Michael Cook, Greg Swann and Jeff Turner. Of the judges, only I saw the articles in their original form. Everyone else saw the versions that I had anonymized.

So: Who won?

Rank Has Its Privileges, and I’m asserting one here. The winner by a significant margin was David Gibbons from Zillow Blog with Attracting a Conversation: Blog Comment Tips. But — I hope without diluting David’s glory — I would like to craft mini-laurels for all of the authors of Zillow Blog’s series on real estate weblogging. Here are the other articles in the series:

And, yes, we’re weblogging about weblogging. But that’s beside the point. The Carnival of Real Estate should celebrate uncontested excellence in real estate weblogging, and David’s post — and the entire Zillow Blog series — are particularly good examples of how to handle this work wisely and well.

But now the pre-game show is over. Here are the top ten winners of the Carnival of Real Estate:

  1. David Gibbons outruns the Colts with Attracting a Conversation: Blog Comment Tips – Zillow Blog posted at Zillow Blog.
  2. REBlogGirl comes in second with Long tail, short tail and coat tail searches posted at Read more

BloodhoundBlog to host February 5th Carnival of Real Estate

So: We’re hitting all 12 cylinders, with two grand slam introductions this week. I should think we would be a slam dunk for next week’s Carnival of Real Estate.

Except…

We’re hosting it. Not this Monday, a week from Monday.

We offered a long time ago to pick up the slack if a hosting blog had to beg off at the last minute. It happened.

This is a cool opportunity for us: Group blog, group judging. We have Cameron working on software we can use to manage the judging process with multiple judges.

We’re also hosting the Carnival of Real Estate Investing on February 19th, with Jeff Brown, Michael Cook and Brian Brady doing the judging.

Plan ahead. Be ready for us. We’ll be ready for you…

Technorati Tags: , ,

Candles, incense, bells and ashes: Redeeming The Carnival of Real Estate . . .

I’ve been very gratified by all the comments we’ve had, both public and private, about raising the standards for The Carnival of Real Estate. We did what we did because we were behind the wheel. We had control of the Carnival for this one week, and it would have been difficult and unseemly to take it away from us. But we didn’t know, going in, if we were going to incite admiration or riots — or simply indifference. Cathleen and I have the advantage of being stridently devoted to doing what we think is right, damn the consequences, but we really do hope to make an enduring change in the way this competition is judged.

No, this is not rocket science, brain surgery, world peace or any other presumptively momentous endeavor deployed fallaciously to diminish every smaller endeavor. But anything worth doing is worth doing well, wisely, completely, coming as close as we can attain to the sublimely perfect. Excellence is ennobling, and to make a habit of excellence is to lead a noble life. And as far from the earth-shakingly momentous as a Carnival of Real Estate entry might be, is is nevertheless a piece of your life — whether you are the writer or the reader — an irreplaceable portion of all the forever you will ever have. Whyever would you waste it?

Even so, the test of all this, going forward, will be what ZillowBlog — owner of The Carnival of Real Estate — elects to do, and then how each hosting weblog interprets any rules ZillowBlog might lay down. Practically speaking, nothing may change, and I am ordinarily a proud advocate of changing nothing. But if nothing changes in the rules and standards of the Carnival, what will change is the quality of the entries. Bad work drives out the good. If people who are thoughtful, talented and assiduous know that they will be held as the nominal equals of competitors who actually bring nothing to the competition, they will stop entering. The Carnival will come to be seen not as the harbinger of excellence but of its opposite.

That Read more

Carnival of Real Estate: Creams and cheeses . . .

This is our list of second-tier winners in the Carnival of Real Estate. Like those we exhibited yesterday, these are all well-developed ideas pertinent to the real estate industry. These are all very worthy posts, the kind I consider eminently link-worthy, because they advance the meta-discussion that is real estate weblogging.

Working from interviews with real estate webloggers, Drew Meyers from Zillow Blog asks Why Do You Blog?

Todd Tarson of MOCO Real Estate News uses a favorite movie quote to lead us on a grand tour of red hot real estate issues.

From True Gotham, Douglas Heddings shares his thoughts on the real estate market in the Hamptons.

Jim Cronin of The Real Estate Tomato points a loaded question at real estate practitioners: “Why Have A Website At All?”

If we take a turn around Mike’s Corner, Michael Price will treat us to a review of Waiting On Your Cat To Bark.

Drop your keyboard and grab your game controller: Daniel Rothamel of The Real Estate Zebra is a Blogger For Frogger.

Writing from his ActiveRain weblog, Jonathan Dalton chronicles Bigfoot, Open MLS and other myths.

David A. Porter of the Pacesetter Mortgage Blog advises us on the Top 4 Critical Questions when buying a Condominium.

Pat Kitano of TransparentRE.com, my kind of over-achiever, delivers a five-part tutorial on real estate weblogging.

From nubricks.com, A. Samuel asks Slough to get a new HeART time for Ricky Gervais to move office?

Renthuiast, a UK weblog, invites us to a Conversation with Nestoria.

Stephen Jagger of Ubertor.com brings an insightful list of Search Engine Keyword Tips.

Our outbound traffic to yesterday’s winners was huge, more than double our normal outbound/inbound ratio — on a very busy day. That’s great, and this is why I wanted to show these posts on a separate day — so that they don’t get lost in the shuffle. Let’s dig in and devour all these delicious creams and cheeses so that tomorrow we can self-flagellate in good conscience…

More: Carnival of Real Estate: Overture…, Carnival of Real Estate: The red meat…, Candles, incense, bells and ashes: Redeeming The Carnival of Real Estate…

Technorati Tags: ,

Carnival of Real Estate: The red meat . . .

The word carnival is devolved from Latin, carne vale, to bid farewell to meat. It refers of course to the French term Mardi gras, fat Tuesday, the day before Ash Wednesday, when good Catholics were expected to either consume or dispose of any animal fats in their possession prior to the onset of Lent. Tomorrow we’ll devour the creams and cheeses. Today shall we feast on the red meat, the Carnival of Real Estate entries that best exemplify the standard of excellence to which every real estate weblog should aspire.

First, and by far best, is Bryan Tutas with The proof is in the puddin’ — Range Pricing part 1,275. Relevance and originality abound in this article, but the shear exuberance of the thing is what put it over the top.

Next comes Mike Simonsen from the Altos Research Real Estate Insights with Home Ownership and the Affordability Red Herring.

Dan Melson of Searchlight Crusade weighs in with Straw Buyer Fraud.

Jon Ernest, The Property Monger, is, as per usual, both factual and funny with Zillowblog sends some love to Boston Real Estate.

Greg Tracy from BlueRoof.com Blog brings us The Battle Between Appraisers and Everyone Else

Jay Thompson, The Phoenix Real Estate Guy, opines on The Ultimate Real Estate Portal.

And Dan Green from The Mortgage Reports Blog tells us that WaPo gets it all wrong about 30-year fixed rate mortgages.

The sequence from second to seventh implies nothing about quality. We felt Bryan Tutas was a cut above everything, but the next six are in a dead heat — but still much better than the next twelve, which in turn were much better than the remaining 24. But these seven are at the level of quality we all should be aiming for, in my opinion: topically relevant, important and fully developed, clear in meaning, purpose and direction, and possessed of that ineffable spark of stylistic genius that makes them not just readable but memorable.

So dig in to the red meat. Tomorrow the feast continues, and then Wednesday it’s sack cloth and ashes. Dominus vobiscum.

More: Carnival of Real Estate: Overture…, Carnival of Real Estate: Creams and cheeses…, Read more

Carnival of Real Estate — Overture . . .

We’re finished judging the entrants for the Carnival of Real Estate. I’m going to roll things out in four posts over four days. I have three reasons for doing this.

  1. I want to draw your particular attention to the posts that were particularly good, and I want for the entrants in the second tier — good but not quite great — to have their own day in the sun.
  2. I want to address in the first and last posts some issues that I think will make the Carnival of Real Estate better and more relevant going forward.
  3. I was accused today of having organized my own weblog posts in a logical sequence, an organizational feat I have never yet achieved.

My post tomorrow will highlight one entry of unsurpassed excellence and six more of surpassing quality. Tuesday morning, we will exhibit a dozen more entries that were very, very good. By Wednesday, I want to talk seriously about laying down some rules for this contest.

Here’s why: We had a total of 43 unique entries. Out of that number, 24 did not make the cut. We had multiple entries from the same weblog, in some cases from the same person. One entry consisted almost entirely of plagiarized text. Another offered advice on how to use constructive mortgage fraud to deceive new-home builders. Many, many, many entries were too short to warrant any sort of consideration. There is nothing at all wrong with writing a very short weblog post — I do it all the time. But a short riff on an undeveloped idea is not a contest entry, it’s a painful reminder to revisit the topic later — conclusively, in greater detail, in fuller mind.

I know the practice until lately has been to make note of every entry, but the number of entries is growing week-by-week, and I don’t think it is any favor to conflate serious attempts to push back the darkness with phoning-it-in cat-blog posts. It’s certainly a disservice to the people striving to do the most and best they can with their weblogs, and it strikes me as being unjust, also, to the Read more