Full disclosure: I’m neither Democrat nor Republican. I’m neither Mortgage Broker nor Mortgage Banker. I am a consumer – just like you.
I haven’t been over here to play as often as I’d like because of some other projects I’ve been passionately pursuing. My bad, because this is still the place to be for people with a take. And I’ve got a take:
What the American public doesn’t know is what makes them the American public, alright?
– Dan Akroyd as Ray Zalinsky in the movie “Tommy Boy”
For the rest of this article to make sense, I’d ask that you take 2 minutes to read this letter authored by Sen. Jeff Merkley to Fed Chair Ben Bernanke dated Dec. 24, 2009.
Here’s the cliff’s notes version the way I read it:
- Mortgage brokers are crooks.
- The subprime debacle happened because consumers were “tricked” into loans they couldn’t afford to repay.
- Eliminating the Yield Spread Premium (YSP) will fix our problems.
To support his argument to kill YSP, Merkley cites a NY Times editorial piece painting the mortgage broker as unethical and the root of the subprime debacle. Here are a few questions I’d like to pose to the pound for thought and discussion:
- YSP existed in its current form up until Jan 1, 2010 – when the new Good Faith Estimate and RESPA rules took effect . By the way, is there still such a thing as a “subprime loan”? What banks are writing “subprime loans” today? Six months ago? A year ago?
- Did it EVER make any sense that a bank would knowingly extend a loan to a borrower who had demonstrated a propensity to default and thus would be more likely than normal to default on their mortgage? Where is the mention of the “stated income” loans in Merkley’s letter. Certainly THAT didn’t contribute to the subprime mess, right?
- FACT: today, the mortgage broker CANNOT earn YSP. YSP belongs to the borrower and may only be rebated to the borrower.
I’m going to repeat that for effect.
- Senator Merkley, less than one month ago
- Authored a letter (co-signed by approximately 20 other Senators)
- In the guise of consumer protection
- Calling for the elimination of Read more



It’s funny, I am almost never at a loss for words. I have an opinion on just about any topic and am usually a passionate conversationalist….but put me in the yard with the Big Dogs and I’m feeling a little puppyish (you’ll find that I like to make up words).
Scott Schang is a long-time contributor to our comments threads. Scott has come to both of the BloodhoundBlog Unchained events held in Phoenix, and he may be the best success story to come of Unchained so far. Scott has devoted his attentions to honing his prospecting and conversion systems, and he’ll be talking to us about that and more.
Harry Bisel has led a rich, full life. A commercial photographer who made the shift into real estate, and then shifted aback out into real estate photography.